Why Founders Should Avoid Unrealistic Valuations For Their Startups

Founders should be cautious about and avoid unrealistic valuations for their startups. That’s something most know, but few understand the complete implications of overstating metrics and misrepresenting facts to investors.

When presenting five-year projections or comparable valuations of similar businesses in your sector, be sure to provide evidence to support the figures. Always remember that investors can see right through you, and losing credibility won’t work in your favor.

Unrealistic projections send the wrong signal, as investors know meeting these estimates will be challenging. You might have to resort to raising a down round, which is detrimental to the company and its investors. So, what exactly are unrealistic and inflated projections? Let’s do a deep dive.

Understanding Inflated Valuations or Overvaluations

An inflated valuation of a startup is when its estimated value is set much higher than its actual worth. This valuation may indicate it is poised for rapid, substantial growth over a short period. In an attempt to impress investors, founders may present overestimates to signal confidence in their business idea.

The objective is to inspire investors to back their startups by indicating a high potential for attractive returns. At the same time, a higher valuation also implies lower risk. However, investors are well-experienced at reading signals because they vet hundreds of applications regularly.

They can instantly recognize an unrealistic valuation, which raises questions about the founder’s business acumen and judgment. You risk investors questioning your research capabilities, your reliance on unverified data, and your inability to assess risk effectively.

Founders should avoid unrealistic valuations for their startups, because investors look beyond inflated numbers. They’re also concerned about the inability to gather and analyze data and the lack of knowledge about the sector in which the founders operate.

Investors are thus more likely to turn their attention to other investment opportunities. If you raise a funding round successfully at this valuation, you’ll find it challenging to meet the projected performance targets.

This can trigger a domino effect, leading to poor spending decisions and unsustainable burn rates that hinder actual growth. You’ll shift attention from fortifying the business to sustaining the unreal metrics, which can ultimately lead to failure.

The pressure to perform often leads employees and investors to feel alienated and lose faith in the company. Conversely, a realistic valuation ensures that you partner with the right investors, whose interests align with the company’s. This partnership will ultimately drive sustainable growth.

Why Founders Should Avoid Unrealistic Valuations for Their Startups – The Risks

Don’t forget that, in addition to your forecasts, investors rely on industry benchmarks for information. They’ll consider the numbers that other startups within your niche demonstrate in terms of excellent performance and valuation.

Investors also compare your startup to companies backed by teams of similar size, skill sets, and experience. Valuing your startup against sector standards through extensive research lends greater credibility to the pitch. But inflated valuations lead to several risks. Here’s what you need to know.

• If investors think they invested more capital than the startup is worth, they will have concerns about their returns. They may also worry about their reputation as savvy investors and market confidence in their investment portfolio.
• Transparency is key to lasting partnerships with investors, and misrepresenting numbers can erode their trust. You risk breaking down the relationship quickly.
• When investors provide capital, they typically have an exit horizon within which they aim to achieve significant returns. Investing in an overvalued startup can make it harder for them to find potential buyers for their stake.
• Founders seeking acquisition or sale opportunities will likely have a smaller pool of buyers interested in the deal. This factor can significantly narrow investors’ exit avenues.
• Startups with an overestimated valuation often sell at a loss. This means that founders owe investors money even after liquidating the business.
• Investors are wary of the risk of a future down round and the resulting dilution and share price decline. They will simply withdraw their support in favor of other investment opportunities.

Remember that if your valuation is reasonable and driven by actual performance metrics and achievable goals, you’ll keep investors engaged. They are more likely to participate in follow-on funding rounds and offer complete flexibility in the resources they can provide.

Impact of Unrealistic Valuations on the Team

Inflated and unrealistic valuations can demoralize not only the founders but also the team. Setting unreasonable projections means you’ll work harder to achieve them, resulting in burnout and impaired decision-making. Invariably, you’ll let stress take over. Don’t let that happen.

Instead, use verifiable data to drive your valuation and set targets that you can meet within the next 18 to 24 months. The company will have growth rates that it can sustain over the next several funding rounds. And that leads to improved morale–not disappointment.

Your focus should be on building a robust business, not justifying the impossible metrics. Employees should be confident that their option pools will likely yield substantial returns and their hard work will pay off.

Avoid the risks of high employee turnover, which requires unnecessary time and resources. The ability to recruit and retain talent is crucial to company building and fundraising.

Impact of Inflated Valuations on Company Operations

Founders should avoid unrealistic valuations for their startups, as they erode investor confidence and trust. Their concern is genuine, as the inflated value will impact how you run operations. In a bid to reach the impossible metrics, you’ll increase spending to accelerate growth.

Higher burn rates don’t always translate into growth spurts, particularly if the company is unstable and cannot sustain them. Founders make the critical mistake of diverting substantial resources to approaches like, say, hiring and marketing. But without a clear strategy to drive higher profits.

Spending cash quickly can be fatal. When you set out to raise the next funding round, investors will analyze the amount you raised. They will want detailed information about how the company used the capital and the return on investment it generated.

For instance, if you spent it on research and development, investors need to see the intellectual property (IP) or products. They’ll want to see market share expansion and revenue growth, and you’ll have to justify the higher valuation.

Many founders overlook market and macroeconomic conditions that can hamper projected growth and metrics. They may also face internal operational challenges, and customers may adopt the products at a slower rate than expected. Not achieving milestones indicates underperformance.

Keep in mind that storytelling is everything in fundraising. In this regard, for a winning pitch deck to help you here, take a look at the template created by Peter Thiel, Silicon Valley legend (see it here), that I recently covered. Thiel was the first angel investor in Facebook with a $500K check that turned into more than $1 billion in cash.

Remember to unlock the pitch deck template that founders worldwide are using to raise millions below.

Ethical, Legal, and Regulatory Risks of Unrealistic Valuations

Don’t overlook the risk of ethical and legal issues that can arise because of unreasonable valuations. Founders resort to misrepresenting traction, falsifying projections, and presenting overly optimistic assumptions that mislead investors.

Their valuations are based on exaggerated revenue, unit economics, product readiness, customer buying commitments, and a strong customer base. Investors will eventually discover that the claims were misleading and that false pretenses were used to secure capital.

The gap between the narrative and reality can have significant fallouts that extend beyond the loss of credibility. Legal accountability is a much bigger risk. Here’s what can happen:

• Investors can pursue legal action claiming that they received inaccurate information. They can force founders to negotiate terms and even block the company from further fundraising.
• Regulatory authorities such as the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) may investigate the company. That is, if they believe it engaged in fraudulent capital raising by providing false information and omitting material facts.
• If the company is found guilty of misrepresenting facts, it may face fines or criminal liability.

On the Flip Side – Risks of Undervaluation

While founders should avoid unrealistic valuations for their startups, the reverse is also true. Be aware of the risks of undervaluing your startup, and excessive dilution is only one of them. Setting a lower-than-optimum value means that you’ll give away more equity to raise the desired capital.

This move can have disastrous effects on the founder’s ownership stake in their own company. As they raise subsequent funding rounds, this ownership percentage becomes significantly smaller.

Founders may find that they are losing control over the company’s decision-making. In the event the company is sold or acquired successfully, they are left with a reduced share of the profits. The loss of control can also lead to a hostile takeover and override the founder’s authority.

Investors with larger equity stakes can vote on decisions to change strategy and operations to serve their interests better. These decisions could conflict with the founder’s vision and steer the company in a direction not originally intended.

Undervaluing the company sends a negative signal to investors who perceive it as a lack of confidence from the founders. Investors may see it as the founders being unsure of the company’s potential, its products, and business model.

They may suspect internal financial, managerial, or operational problems that haven’t been disclosed. You can expect them to be overly cautious and to conduct more rigorous due diligence that can extend and delay closing the funding round.

You can also expect to offer higher interest rates and more favorable terms and conditions to secure capital. This is why an accurate valuation is crucial for the founder to maintain a meaningful stake in the company– and not just attract funding. They need the control to ensure its future success.

Creating an Optimum Balance with Accurate Valuation

Valuations—whether unrealistic or undervalued—can be detrimental to a company, its founders, investors, and employees. Even if you successfully raise funding in this round, future rounds will present greater challenges. Investor and employee dissatisfaction are some of the other hurdles.

Understanding how to value your company can be confusing, considering the different aspects that go into arriving at an accurate number. Not sure how to do that? Check out this video in which I have explained how it’s done.

So, what should be your strategy?

Your best solution is to engage an expert fundraising consultant to help you navigate valuation complexities. The professional will ensure your valuation is grounded in verified market research and industry benchmarks. They will also leverage customer feedback for accurate projections.

You’ll conduct a detailed analysis of your company’s assets, including fixed, moving, and intangible assets, such as intellectual property (IP). Also factor in its market position and reach, the team’s expertise, and the company’s overall growth potential.

Compile metrics like churn rates, customer acquisition costs (CAC), lifetime value (LTV) generated, and more. These numbers signal a clear pathway toward assured profitability. When you present these numbers to investors, be transparent about your assumptions and growth projections.

That’s how you’ll build trust and credibility. Rest assured that investors understand uncertain market conditions and unexpected downturns. But once you’ve built a robust relationship with them, you can expect them to maintain support. They’ll align their objectives with yours regardless of conditions.

On your part, ensure that you run lean operations with a clear focus on capital efficiency. Stretch every dollar and find your product-market fit before going all in aggressively. Underscore agility in your strategizing and develop game plans around current market trends.

If the market conditions are favorable, you can leverage positive sentiment and present higher valuations. However, if the conditions are less than favorable, you could delay fundraising until things improve. If you absolutely need capital, spotlight the company’s resilience and risk tolerance.

Your pitch should highlight its long-term viability, cost-efficient burn rates, unique value proposition, and adaptability.

What if your startup is pre-revenue and has a low valuation?

If your startup has a low valuation, you can leverage other strategies to attract investor interest. For instance, consider approaching angel investors who can add more value than just capital. You’ll rely on them for expertise and a credible entity on the cap table.

Also, consider raising capital through instruments such as SAFEs and convertible notes, which allow investors to acquire discounted equity later. You can use the capital to scale the company until it demonstrates traction and achieves a higher valuation.

The Takeaway!

Founders should avoid unrealistic valuations for their startups. When setting a price for the company, resist the impulse to present an inflated valuation. Be wary of the downsides of misrepresenting unfounded assumptions and unverifiable numbers.

Your focus should be on building trust and credibility with investors. Never lose sight of the fact that this is only the beginning of many funding rounds. You’ll need their backing every step of the way.

You may also find our free library of business templates interesting. There, you will find every single template you need to build and scale your business completely, all for free. See it here.